Affluent Detritus

Talking frivolous nonsense while the world burns

Perfume, Review

A tale of two perfumes

I initially tried shoehorning this into an Instagram post, which was incredibly frustrating, but then I remembered I pay hosting fees and don’t have to shrink a block of text into a stupid font and attempt to take aesthetic photos in my dusty living room to convey my feelings about some scents. Let’s get my money’s worth and update this blog more than once in a calendar year!

I am admittedly Very Into Scents but not a big fan of most perfumes. That doesn’t stop me from trying, but I’d say 99% of these ventures are a bust. I want a scent to be just so, perfect and nostalgic and subtly reflecting who I am and who I want to be, but not too strong, or weak, or involving sandalwood or jasmine, and also not cost $400. A tall order. I sometimes find success with a scent for a certain season or mood, but I’m never going to be one of those people with a signature scent. How did this concept get sold to us as a necessary thing, anyway? It feels very “quiet luxury” and “only French girls know how to do their hair or wear lipstick” and other beauty magazine myths invented to make you feel small and sell things. Maybe if I were Isabella Rossellini and lived a beautiful, calm life in a restored farmhouse with heated floors and had a perfect pair of $800 black pants that went with everything and started each morning gazing serenely out a window while sipping tea, I could do a signature scent. But I contain multitudes and am living in chaos. I want to choose my daily scent on a whim like that evil queen chose heads in the freaky Fairuza Balk Oz movie of my childhood.

Naughty girrrrrrl!

I tried Merit’s new perfume New Wave at Sephora several weeks ago, initially on the paper tester. (Who is out there boldly and blindly spraying unknown scents willy-nilly on their own skin?! I hate the way the term rawdogging has pervaded everyday life but it works here. Watching people online liberally dousing themselves to test a new scent is horrifying to me. You do a baby spritz and make sure it isn’t a monster first! Come on!) Anyway: loved it on the paper tester. Sprayed it on my own wrist and was knocked over by straight-up kerosene. However. As it dried down, the kerosene went away and it unfolded into something nicer, sort of golden and spicy and elusive. I was huffing my own wrist every few seconds like a crazy person, trying to determine if I liked it. I wore it home and offered my wrist up to my husband for a sniff. He raised his eyebrows and said, “Oooh, that could be nice.” It could be nice! The world could be different! We could have nice things and not live in fear and tumult and have heated floors in our restored farmhouses, or at least not spend $100 filling up our cars with gas.

I spent the rest of the day sniffing my wrist like it was my job, my little mouse ears and whiskers twitching, trying so hard to fall in love. This scent reminded me of other scents I’ve loved. When I was in college, I had a bottle of Calvin Klein Obsession. I liked to spray it in my dorm room but rarely wore it. It was a bit Too Much for a 19-year-old who survived on the late-night Wendy’s drive-thru and had a boyfriend with duct-taped combat boots, but it nudged a captivating place in my brain. (Did you know that Calvin Klein Obsession attracts tigers? Again, enticing, but just not who I was ready to be at 19.) I feel similarly about Chanel No. 5. Since college, I’ve always kept a bottle on my shelf, but I only wear it to parties in December. Chanel No. 5 is not really who I am the other months of the year, but I really love it for those festive freezing nights.

So my interest was piqued by New Wave, but wanted it to smell more like it did on the paper than it did on my skin. This is the way that darn coyote gets me every time! A few weeks later, I was stocking up on old standards during the Sephora sale and thought oooh, why not, let’s have some fun and added New Wave to my cart. Let’s try and make this work! When we don’t even have to and there are other options to explore! Yes this was exactly how my dating life used to be back in the day!

I bought it, and then it arrived and I didn’t spray it, and then I went on a trip and didn’t pack it, even though it was the small travel size. I was then fed an Instagram ad that made me roll my eyes but also click to learn more.

I am old enough to know better but still curious

The perfume in the ad was Citiette by Maison Millais. I read some online reviews and determined it was probably too woody for me. Try as I might, I am not a Sofia Coppola girl. But I could see the notes of the other scents they carried, and I was intrigued by (please know that I also hate this name but if there’s one thing I know, it’s that love can sneak up and punch you in the throat like this):

We can all take a moment to sigh at this; it’s okay. Also I must admit that 25-year-old me would’ve LOVED this name. Her NYC big girl life was also life-ing, and she’s still in here somewhere, demanding her turn to choose a head for the day. Sometimes we have to indulge her, and it’s usually pretty fun when we do.

So I ordered their discovery set and fell in love. FLTWAVIDP sang where New Wave sagged. They both have notes of amber and resin, but the difference, for me, is everything. It’s still very much a winter scent for me, but I want to wear it every day so far. This is intimate candlelight instead of kerosene, a glow instead of a smudge. I kept sniffing my own wrist because it was there and I wanted more, not because I was trying desperately to find it. Not to tie a bow on it, but this feels like me. Never settle! The lesson I must learn over and over again, no matter how insignificant the stakes.

I’m off to sip my morning tea while I watch my grazing tigers through the window. Don’t worry; the house is a mess.

Share this:

Leave a Reply